Herpetic Keratitis Recurred after the Use of a Thermal Medical Device: A Case Report

Dear Editor,

Herpetic keratitis is a relatively common disease known to respond well to treatment, but relapses are common. Numerous studies have reported the incidence is 0.01% to 0.02% with recurrence rates estimated to be 40% to 50% within 5 years [1]. Herpes simplex virus (HSV) replicates itself to infect the sensory axons of the cornea and infiltrate to the neurons inside the trigeminal ganglia. Even if treatment is completed, the ganglion is subjected to a series of steps to activate the transcription substance of the viral genome for reactivation immediately [1]. Because the recurrence is associated with poor visual prognosis, much effort is required to prevent recurrence. In recent studies, heat stress has been known to influence on reactivation of HSV [2]. Thermal therapy became popular as a treatment for meibomian gland dysfunction and dry eye syndrome, but studies of side effects are lacking. We try to report a rare case of herpetic keratitis recurred after the use of a thermal medical device.

A 67-year-old female patient presented with foreign body sensation and decreased visual acuity in her right eye for several days. The patient had no medical history except hypertension. She had been diagnosed with herpetic keratitis 5 years ago for the first time and had histories of recurrent herpetic keratitis 1 year and 6 months ago. Visual acuity of right eye was 20/800 and the intraocular pressure was 10 mmHg. A slit lamp examination showed a dendrite lesions stained with fluorescein, corneal edema, stromal infiltration, and keratic precipitates (Fig. 1A). There were no inflammatory cells in the anterior chamber and no abnormal findings on fundus examination. The patient told symptoms had been worse since taking a thermal medical device (Rapha402; Rapha Medical, Seoul, Korea) every morning and night for 5 minutes each, for 10 days. The device was applied directly on the posterior portion of eyelid and direct contact to ocular surface was not happened. The temperature range of the device was from 36°C to 45°C. As no definite reason affecting recurrence was observed other than this thermal device, we diagnosed as recurrent herpetic keratitis caused by heat stress and treated with topical ganciclovir 0.15%. After confirming corneal epithelial lesion improvement, the patient was treated with oral methylprednisolone with tapering to minimize corneal opacity. After 3 months of topical antiviral and steroid therapy, visual acuity was 20/40 and the corneal lesion was recovered except corneal opacity (Fig. 1B). No recurrence happened for 1 year.

Fig. 1

Anterior segment photographs after the use of thermal therapy device. (A) On the first day of recurrence, corneal dendritic lesions (arrows), corneal edema, keratic precipitate, and stromal infiltration were observed. (B) After 3 months of treatment, only corneal opacity was remained. The patient provided written informed consent for publication of the research details and clinical images.

Generally, immune status, trauma, heat, and emotional stress are known as the cause of recurrence in HSV infections [2]. In our case, thermal stress was estimated to have affected HSV reactivation based on two points. At first, right eye that has already had history of recurrence and thought to be vulnerable to reactivation was the only one to recur although the device was applied on both eyes. Secondly, the lesion was occurred right after the use of thermal device. There are reports that heat stress plays an important role in reactivation of HSV. Halford et al. [3] demonstrated reactivation of HSV was related to heat stress duration. The ganglion cells were incubated in a thermostat at 43°C in experiment group and normal environment in control group, and were compared by the reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction. In the experiment group, infectious virus appeared in 75% after thermal stress [3]. Another study reported the latent infection with type I HSV in mice placed in water at 43°C for 10 minutes, and reactivation of the HSV was observed in the cornea [4]. The device used in this case had a laser irradiation function with a wavelength of 650 nm and a thermal function at 45°C. Since 650 nm is known to have no significant change to cornea, the lesion does not seem to be affected by laser function and thermal function applied to the eye may trigger the reactivation of virus remained in the trigeminal ganglion and induce the recurrence of keratitis [5].

Although limitations of this case are the evidence of the herpetic keratitis recurrence induced by 36°C to 45°C indirect thermal stress has not been fully provided, and only one patient report and further review of the feasibility of such case collection will be needed, patients with a history of herpetic keratitis should be cautious about the recurrence when using the thermal medical device because heat stress may reactivate the virus.